I’ve spent the last year turning my home into an indoor farm, testing everything from high-end AI towers to budget Amazon finds. While growing flowers, fruits, and vegetables without soil is rewarding, I discovered a secret the brands don’t want you to know: many of these systems are identical “white-label” clones.
In this guide, I’m cutting through the marketing to show you which gardens actually offer unique tech and which ones are just the same hardware with a different logo. If you want to avoid the “clones” and find the best system for your specific space, here is my honest breakdown of the systems I’ve actually put to the test.
Table of Contents
Note: Some links in this post may contain affiliate links, which means at no cost to you, I may earn a commission.
The Truth About White-Label Systems
One of the biggest realizations I had during testing was seeing identical structures across different brands. For example, the Sainlogic 12-pod system is indistinguishable from the Hdroor 12-pod system. They use the same pump, the same light spectrum, and the same plastic molds. In fact, it is the same, just with a different logo and color.
My Advice: When shopping for a basic starter kit, don’t pay a premium for the brand name. If you see two systems that look identical, check the design and pod count – they’re likely coming from the same factory, and you should just buy whichever is currently on sale.
At-a-Glance: My Top Tested Picks by Category
After months of monitoring water levels, light cycles, and actual crop yields, these are the only systems that would earn a permanent spot in my home. I’ve narrowed down my top-tested picks based on where they actually excel and where they outperform the clones.
| Category | My Top Pick | The "Why" |
|---|---|---|
|
Overall Favorite |
Best yield, visually stunning with the plants growing out of it, and the camera monitoring with AI features makes sure plants are healthy |
|
|
Best Value |
The most reliable “no frills” worker for the price. |
|
|
Best for Vining Plants |
Only one with the height and trellis support for tall heavy vines. |
|
|
Best Looking |
Minimalist, high-end design that looks great in a kitchen |
|
|
Best Tech / App |
Smart features and WiFi enabled to monitor lights and water level at a reasonable price |
The "White-Label" Secret: Are You Overpaying for a Logo?
One of the most important things I discovered while testing these systems is that the brand name on the front often doesn’t matter. Take the Sainlogic 12-pod system, for example. After comparing it side-by-side with the Hdroor 12-pod model, it’s clear they are identical white-label clones. They share the exact same hardware, from the design to the water pump to the LED light spectrum.
My Expert Advice: When you’re shopping for a standard 12-pod desktop garden, don’t feel like you have to stick to one “big” brand.
Check the images: This is honestly the easiest way to tell. If the listing photos are the same, it is the same!
Price is King: Since the hardware is the same, buy whichever one is cheaper that day. I’ve seen the Hdroor listed for $20 less than the Sainlogic despite them being the same machine.
The Exception: Only pay a premium if the system offers something significantly better, such as an app, or it comes with seeds, or it has unique features like the built-in trellis found on the eSuperegrow.
The Tech Behind the Garden: How it Works
At its simplest, an indoor hydroponic garden is a soil-free way to grow plants using only water, light, and nutrients. But having tested a dozen of these, I’ve realized it’s more than just a “set it and forget it” gadget. These systems use either a pump-based (active) or wicking (passive) method to deliver minerals directly to the roots.
The real benefit isn’t just faster growth, it’s the ability to grow “out of season” vegetables in your kitchen without the mess of dirt or the threat of outdoor pests. However, as you’ll see in my reviews below, the “automation” varies wildly between a $50 clone and a $800 professional tower.
Don’t forget to pin it so you can come back to the list later!
Get the latest DIY tutorials, reviews, and crafting updates
You'll never be spammed and can unsubscribe at any time
Reviews of Each Hydroponic Garden
Gardyn Home Kit 4.0
The Gardyn Home Kit 4.0 is the ultimate indoor hydroponic garden and is my favorite from the list. It is by far the largest garden kit so if you want to go all-out and grow nearly a full produce aisle in your home, then this is your kit! It only takes up 2 square feet of space on the ground, but it takes advantage of the vertical space at roughly 5 feet tall. It even comes with 2 cameras that monitor your plants’ growth and will automatically create time lapse videos for you (I’ve had a lot of fun with this)!
While this kit is also the most expensive, by a significant amount, you do get 30 days free of their app, Kelby, which keeps an eye on your plants and uses AI to let you know when to harvest, add nutrients, add water, or if there are any issues.
I don’t think I could justify the price for myself, but now that I have one, it is absolutely the best kit out there.
Tester’s Note: I love the AI camera that tells you when to add water and makes the time lapse videos!
KEY FEATURES
- Number of Pods: 30
- Max Light Height: N/A
- Air Pump: Yes
- Seeds Included?: Yes, choose from 3 collections: culinary, herbalist, and decor (mine was the culinary collection)
- Water Level Meter: No (monitored in-app)
- Nutrients: Included
- Special Features: AI-powered growth monitoring, app control
PROS
- Number of Plants – It can grow the most plants – up to 30
- Video Monitoring – It comes with cameras to monitor your plants’ growth and automatically create time lapse videos
- Small Floor Space – It takes up similar amount of floor space, but can grow much more than other systems
- Cool Looking with Plants – With plants fully growing, it can look like a living wall
CONS
- Price – It’s the most expensive system
- Features Cost Extra – The advertised AI can be misleading. The AI functionality, Kelby, is only included with their membership which is around $30 per month (though it does give you roughly $20 in store credit each month + free shipping to get new plants)
- Unattractive without Plants – Before there are plants growing on it, the garden is aesthetically unappealing as it effectively looks like 3 large PVC pipes
URUQ 12-Pod System with Remote
The URUQ 12-Pod hydroponics growing system with remote is an incredible value as it grows a lot, has a simple design, and comes with the necessary nutrients. Although it doesn’t come with seeds, it does come with nutrients and an adjustable light up to 21 inches.
Tester’s Note: I love the easy to read water level meter on this one!
KEY FEATURES
- Number of Pods: 12
- Max Light Height: Up to 21 inches
- Air Pump: Yes
- Seeds Included?: No
- Water Level Meter: Yes (front of the tank)
- Nutrients: Included, 2 separate bottles
- Special Features: Touch screen removable remote
PROS
- Number of Plants – It can grow up to 12 plants
- Height – It has one of the tallest light heights at up to 21 inches
- Easy to Read Water-Level – The water level is the one of the easiest to read as you can see the amount of water in the tank
- Remote – The removable remote is great to be able to easily make adjustments – for example most of my gardens is set up on a wire rack, making it difficult to press buttons on the top of the machine, but I can easily grab the remote of this one and then place it back when I’m finished.
CONS
- No Seeds – It doesn’t come with seeds so those need to be purchased separately.
- Mix Nutrients – While it comes with nutrients, you need to add your own water and mix it. It is also two separate bottles that you need to add.
eSuperegrow Indoor Hydroponic Garden
The eSuperegrow indoor hydroponic garden system is designed specifically for plants that require trellising. So if you want to grow items such as flowering vines, cucumbers, or small pumpkins, squashes, and other fruiting vines then this is definitely the one you want to consider.
Tester’s Note: I absolutely love how tall this one gets and the included trellises are so useful!
KEY FEATURES
- Number of Pods: 2
- Max Light Height: 28 inches
- Air Pump: Yes
- Seeds Included?: No
- Water Level Meter: Yes
- Nutrients: Included
- Special Features: Trellis
PROS
- Height – It’s the tallest with a height of 28 inches
- Trellis – It includes a trellis to help support vining plants
- Funnel – It comes with a funnel to easily refill the water tank. I don’t know how this is the only system I’ve seen with a funnel, but oh my goodness is it helpful!
- Water Level Meter – It has an easy to read water level meter
CONS
- Number of Plants – It only grows 2 plants
- Growing Medium – It uses LECA (small clay balls) as the grow medium so small seeds can drop through them and get lost
- Short Power Cord – The power cord connects to the light instead of the base so as you raise the light, the cord gets more taught. This is additionally problematic as the cord is extremely short to begin with (it’s the only system I have that requires its own extension cord)
- No Seeds – It doesn’t come with seeds so those need to be purchased separately.
Click and Grow Smart Garden 9
The Click and Grow Smart Garden 9 is ideal for those looking for a sleek design. It’s on the larger side as it’s wide, but more narrow than most of the gardens. It can hold 9 pods that are spaced nice and far apart, ensuring they all get enough light. You can choose from their beautiful color selection (the one I chose was part of their limited edition collection – sage).
Tester’s Note: I loved not having to add nutrients!
Use coupon code ABCRAFTY for 10% off at Click and Grow!
KEY FEATURES
- Number of Pods: 9
- Max Light Height: Fixed at 12 inches
- Air Pump: No
- Seeds Included?: Yes (3 thyme, 3 basil, 3 parsley)
- Water Level Meter: Yes, but difficult to read
- Nutrients: None, not needed
- Special Features: Wicking Technology
PROS
- Design – Sleek Design
- Pre-Seeded Pods – It comes with pre-seeded pods
CONS
- Water Level Difficult to Read – While it has a water level meter, it’s difficult to understand it. When it’s “full” it’s supposed to be flush with the top of the base, but because it’s rounded it’s difficult to know when that is. I find myself pushing the meter down to watch it bob back up and use that as a reference for the water level.
- Price – It’s expensive for not having nutrients or an air pump
- No Air Pump – It doesn’t have an air pump so it works by gradually wicking water from the basin to the plants, similar to my Modern Sprout Terra Cotta Bonsai Kit
- No Nutrients – It doesn’t come with any nutrients, which I find very difficult to understand. I asked the team and the assured me the nutrients are within the seed pods. While that might be the case, for long term plant health you would need to continue to add nutrients as the plants use them up.
- Height – The height of the lights cannot be moved
You May Also Like...
AeroGarden Harvest Elite
AeroGarden’s Harvest Elite is the classic (and possibly original?) hydroponic garden. It at least set the concept on the map. This was my first hydroponic system so it’s what I learned on, discovering what I do and don’t like in a hydroponic kit. If you’re looking for a name-brand item or to give as a gift, this is a solid choice.
Tester’s Note: Its reliability makes this a classic, but it has become pricey compared to new competitors.
KEY FEATURES
- Number of Pods: 6
- Max Light Height: Up to 12 inches
- Air Pump: Yes
- Seeds Included?: Yes, choose from 4 mixes or a “grow anything” set
- Water Level Meter: No (but can use the click screen)
- Nutrients: Included
- Special Features: Digital Display
PROS
- Design – Sleek Design
- Pre-Seeded Pods – It comes with pre-seeded pods (Genovese Basil, Curly Parsley, Dill, Thyme, Thai Basil, and Mint)
- Digital Display – There’s a sleek front display that displays all of the information digitally
CONS
- No Easy Water Level Meter – There isn’t an easy-to-read water level meter. A light will turn on when it’s time to add water.
- Price – It’s expensive for only holding 6 pods
LetPot LPH-SE Indoor Hydroponic Garden
The LetPot LPH-SE stands out with its Wi-Fi connectivity and app integration, making it easier to monitor your garden remotely. It also has a spacious 12-pod design and my favorite easy to read water level meter with clear min and max lines.
Tester’s Note: This is the only other system I tested other than the Gardyn that could monitor water levels through the app. It’s really a great feature!
KEY FEATURES
- Number of Pods: 12
- Max Light Height: Up to 20 inches
- Air Pump: Yes
- Seeds Included?: No
- Water Level Meter: Yes
- Nutrients: Included, 2 separate bottles
- Special Features: Wi-Fi connectivity, app integration
PROS
- Number of Plants – It can grow up to 12 plants
- Height – It has one of the tallest light heights at up to 20 inches
- Water Level Meter – The water level is my favorite as it’s a simple design with clear min and max water lines
- App – It includes an app that monitors the lights and water level.
CONS
- No Seeds – It doesn’t come with seeds so those need to be purchased separately.
- Mix Nutrients – While it comes with nutrients, you need to add your own water and mix it. It is also two separate bottles that you need to add.
The 12-Pod "Essentials" Group: Sainlogic, Hdroor, and Identical White-Labeled Models
I have incredibly mixed feelings about this specific category of gardens. While they are the most affordable way to grow 12 plants at once, they are also the biggest offenders of the white-label issue. Whether the logo says Sainlogic or Hdroor, you’re getting the same hardware—and the same quirks.
The “Demon Cat” Problem: Beyond the branding issues, the first unit I received had a hardware defect that caused it to beep every minute. Once I got a working unit, I discovered that when the water runs low, the pump makes a sound I can only describe as a demon fighting an ill-tempered cat. It is not a subtle “refill me” reminder; it’s a household disruption.
The Height Limitation: The biggest flaw is the fixed light height. As you can see in my photo of the dwarf sunflowers, they quickly surpassed the LEDs. Since the arm doesn’t tilt or extend further, I had to physically pull the plants to the side to keep them from burning. If you want to grow anything taller than 10 inches, you’re essentially SOL.
KEY FEATURES
- Number of Pods: 12
- Max Light Height: Up to 12 inches
- Air Pump: Yes
- Seeds Included?: No
- Water Level Meter: Yes
- Nutrients: Included, 2 separate bottles
- Special Features: Wi-Fi connectivity, app integration
PROS
- Number of Plants – It can grow up to 12 plants
- Water Level Meter – Super simple water level meter that clearly shows the min and max lines. One of my favorites!
CONS
- No Seeds – It doesn’t come with seeds so those need to be purchased separately.
- Mix Nutrients – While it comes with nutrients, you need to add your own water and mix it. It is also two separate bottles that you need to add.
- Fixed Height – The height is not only on the shorter side, but also it can’t tilt, making it difficult to plant anything that will grow more than 10 inches.
- The “Liar” App: The app can toggle lights, but it doesn’t monitor water levels. Calling it a “Smart Garden” is a stretch.
Hydroponic Troubleshooting: Solutions for Light Burn, Crowding, and Water Loss
| Problem | Likely Cause | The Fix |
|---|---|---|
|
Crispy or Brown Leaf Tips |
Light Burn: The LED panel is too close to the foliage. |
Raise the light arm to its maximum height. If it’s still too close, prune the top third of the plant or stick to “dwarf” varieties in shorter systems. |
|
Stunted Growth |
Light Stealing: Taller plants are shading out the shorter ones. |
Always group plants by similar height. If one plant is blocking its neighbors, prune it back often to let the light reach the bottom canopy. |
|
Low Water Alarms (Frequent) |
High Transpiration: Large, thirsty plants are drinking faster than the tank can hold. |
For large systems like the ones with 12 pods, add an external water source (like a reservoir hack). For smaller units, check levels every 2–3 days once plants are mature. |
|
Loud Pump Noises |
Low Water or Air Bubble: The pump is sucking air or has debris. |
Ensure the water is always above the “Min” line. If it still makes noise, unplug for 10 seconds to let air bubbles escape the internal housing. |
Where to Get Seeds for your Indoor Hydroponic Garden
Not all indoor hydroponic garden systems come with pre-seeded pods. Or you may have specifically chosen a kit so you can use your own seeds. If you’re in one of these situations, here are a few recommendations for where I get my seeds for better variety than what you can get at the big box stores:
- Botanical Interests
- Seed Needs
- Etsy – I’ve gotten a bunch from the seller SeedGeeks, for example
- Eden Brothers (use code ABCRAFTY for 10% off!)
- Amazon
- Rare Seeds
1 thought on “I Tested 10+ Indoor Hydroponic Gardens: The Best (and Worst) for 2026”
a built in timelapse camera would be nice thing for this sorta thing is the equivalant to a cat collar camera or something because is easy to see how the plants are growing and all is might need tip that potentialy might leek or something but is helpful to gardening these seem pretty good but i think is crucial step in the evolution of these things